Quadruple Amputee Cornhole Pro Accused of Murder: Ex-Girlfriend Details ‘Angry Dark Side’
A professional cornhole player, who is a quadruple amputee, has been accused of a brutal murder, with his ex-girlfriend revealing a history of volatile outbursts and a disturbing “angry dark side.” Dayton Webber, 27, is facing charges after allegedly shooting and killing his passenger, Bradrick Michael Wells, 27, during a heated argument inside Webber’s Tesla SUV in La Plata, Maryland, on March 22.
Tori Mattingly, who was in a four-year relationship with Webber before their breakup in February 2025, stated she was not surprised by the allegations. She told media outlets that she had ended her relationship with Webber due to his anger issues and had even encouraged him to seek therapy, which he reportedly refused.
Mattingly also revealed that she had a relationship with the victim, Bradrick Michael Wells, after her split from Webber. She stated that Webber was aware of their on-and-off relationship and that Wells and Webber were acquainted. The Charles County Sheriff’s Office confirmed that all individuals involved in the incident were known to each other.
Mattingly shared that she had not been in contact with Webber for months and last spoke to Wells in December, on her birthday. She described Webber’s behaviour as frequently “lashing out.” In one instance, captured on video, Webber can be heard yelling at Mattingly for not allowing him to use her car.
During the recorded exchange, Mattingly asks, “I asked you if you wanted to take the vehicle,” to which Webber responds aggressively, “And I asked you to get off my property.” When Mattingly questions his behaviour, citing his request to be “nice,” Webber reiterates, “I asked you to get off my property,” before walking away.
A Troubled Past and Public Accusations
Mattingly also took to social media to address her past relationship with Webber, expressing her dismay at those who doubted his capacity for such violence. “Watching people say ‘this doesn’t sound like him’ or ‘he would never do that’ is honestly sickening,” she wrote on Facebook. “You didn’t live with him. I did.”
She claimed that her four years living with Webber exposed her to “the side of him that nobody else wanted to believe existed.” Mattingly detailed experiences of “anger, control, abuse, the kind of darkness you don’t just ‘mistake.'” She described this darkness as being so profound that it made her feel “unsafe in your own home, in your own skin.”
Mattingly emphasized that she was not shocked by the accusations against Webber, stating, “I know what he’s capable of.” She added, “You saw the version he wanted you to see. I saw the truth. And just because he didn’t show you that side doesn’t mean it wasn’t real. It just means I was the one he chose to break behind closed doors.”
The Alleged Incident and Investigation
Reports indicate that Webber allegedly shot Wells twice in the head before attempting to enlist other passengers to help dispose of the body. According to charging documents from the Charles County Sheriff’s Office, Webber had picked up two individuals from their work and brought them into the back of his white Tesla, where Wells was already seated in the passenger seat.
During the drive, a “heated argument” reportedly erupted between Webber and Wells. At the height of the altercation, Webber allegedly produced a firearm and fired two shots at Wells’ head.
Following the shooting, Webber is accused of pulling over the vehicle and asking the two passengers to assist in removing Wells from the car. Both passengers refused and fled the scene, subsequently contacting law enforcement. Webber then allegedly drove away with Wells’ body still inside the Tesla.
Wells’ body was later discovered in a yard on Newport Church Road in Charlotte Hall, Maryland. Detectives successfully tracked Webber’s Tesla to Charlottesville, Virginia, where he was apprehended at a hospital receiving treatment for an unspecified medical issue. He has been charged with first-degree murder and second-degree murder.
During a court hearing in Charlottesville on Thursday, Webber waived his right to an extradition hearing, stating, “I am trying to go back to Maryland.”
Questions Surrounding the Circumstances
Webber’s case has raised significant questions about how a quadruple amputee could have allegedly driven a vehicle, operated a firearm, and, as reported, attempted to move a body from the Tesla. Diane Richardson, a public information officer for the Charles County Sheriff’s Office, acknowledged these concerns, stating that Webber is a “well-documented individual on the internet.” She noted that “there’s a lot of stories of him handling firearms” on platforms like YouTube and other social media.
Webber’s medical history indicates that his arms and legs were amputated when he was just 10 months old due to a severe blood infection that doctors believed was life-threatening.
Media outlets have reportedly reached out to Mattingly and Webber’s attorney, Alexander Goodman, for further comment.
